The Best Timothy Hay 2024

Updated On September 11th, 2022

Looking for the best Timothy Hay? You aren't short of choices in 2022. The difficult bit is deciding the best Timothy Hay for you, but luckily that's where we can help. Based on testing out in the field with reviews, sells etc, we've created this ranked list of the finest Timothy Hay.

Rank Product Name Score
1
Kaytee Forti-Diet All Natural Timothy Hay

Kaytee Forti-Diet All Natural Timothy Hay

Check Price
92%
2
Kaytee Forti-Diet All Natural Timothy Hay , 48 ounce

Kaytee Forti-Diet All Natural Timothy Hay , 48 ounce

Check Price
92%
3
Kaytee Forti-Diet All Natural Timothy Hay , 96 ounce

Kaytee Forti-Diet All Natural Timothy Hay , 96 ounce

Check Price
92%
4
Kaytee All Natural Alfalfa Mini Bale Small Animal Food , 24.0 OZ

Kaytee All Natural Alfalfa Mini Bale Small Animal Food , 24.0 OZ

Check Price
90%
5
Extreme Timothy Hay 96oz

Extreme Timothy Hay 96oz

Check Price
84%
6
CareFresh Timothy Hay Small Animal Food, 32 Oz

CareFresh Timothy Hay Small Animal Food, 32 Oz

Check Price
74%
7
Extreme Timothy Hay 48oz

Extreme Timothy Hay 48oz

Check Price
68%
8
Small Pet Select Hand Made Hay Manger, Large

Small Pet Select Hand Made Hay Manger, Large

Check Price
0%
9
Extreme! Botanical Hay 24oz

Extreme! Botanical Hay 24oz

Check Price
0%
10
Small Pet Select - Flower Power Berry Boost Herbal Blend

Small Pet Select - Flower Power Berry Boost Herbal Blend

Check Price
0%

1. Kaytee Forti-Diet All Natural Timothy Hay

Kaytee Forti-Diet All Natural Timothy Hay
92%

Our Score

Kaytee feeds more hay to small pets than anyone else. We pride ourselves on providing fresh, tasty, all-natural hay. Grown specifically for small animals, timothy hay is hand selected to ensure long fiber strands and a proper leaf to stem ratio to support your small pet’s digestive health. We understand that taste matters. Kaytee Forti Diet timothy hay tastes better because it is naturally grown and harvested with care. Our hay is grown in fertile farmland graced with abundant sunlight and nourished by cool, rocky mountain water. Naturally grown without pesticides or artificial ingredients, our farmers only grow supreme grade hay. This means, high quality and superior nutrition for your small pet. At Kaytee, we are committed to harvesting the best nature has to offer. Satisfaction Guaranteed or your money back.

Naturally grown without pesticides Grown specifically for small animals High fiber to support digestive health America's #1 Hay Brand All Natural non GMO ingredient No artificial preservatives

2. Kaytee Forti-Diet All Natural Timothy Hay , 48 ounce

Kaytee Forti-Diet All Natural Timothy Hay , 48 ounce
92%

Our Score

Kaytee feeds more hay to small pets than anyone else. We pride ourselves on providing fresh, tasty, all-natural hay. Grown specifically for small animals, timothy hay is hand selected to ensure long fiber strands and a proper leaf to stem ratio to support your small pet’s digestive health. We understand that taste matters. Kaytee Forti Diet timothy hay tastes better because it is naturally grown and harvested with care. Our hay is grown in fertile farmland graced with abundant sunlight and nourished by cool, rocky mountain water. Naturally grown without pesticides or artificial ingredients, our farmers only grow supreme grade hay. This means, high quality and superior nutrition for your small pet. At Kaytee, we are committed to harvesting the best nature has to offer. Satisfaction Guaranteed or your money back.

Naturally grown without pesticides Grown specifically for small animals High fiber to support digestive health America's #1 Hay Brand All Natural non GMO ingredient No artificial preservatives

3. Kaytee Forti-Diet All Natural Timothy Hay , 96 ounce

Kaytee Forti-Diet All Natural Timothy Hay , 96 ounce
92%

Our Score

Kaytee feeds more hay to small pets than anyone else. We pride ourselves on providing fresh, tasty, all-natural hay. Grown specifically for small animals, timothy hay is hand selected to ensure long fiber strands and a proper leaf to stem ratio to support your small pet’s digestive health. We understand that taste matters. Kaytee Forti Diet timothy hay tastes better because it is naturally grown and harvested with care. Our hay is grown in fertile farmland graced with abundant sunlight and nourished by cool, rocky mountain water. Naturally grown without pesticides or artificial ingredients, our farmers only grow supreme grade hay. This means, high quality and superior nutrition for your small pet. At Kaytee, we are committed to harvesting the best nature has to offer. Satisfaction Guaranteed or your money back.

Naturally grown without pesticides Grown specifically for small animals High fiber to support digestive health America's #1 hay brand All Natural non GMO ingredient No artificial preservatives

4. Kaytee All Natural Alfalfa Mini Bale Small Animal Food , 24.0 OZ

Kaytee All Natural Alfalfa Mini Bale Small Animal Food , 24.0 OZ
90%

Our Score

Kaytee All-Natural Alfalfa Mini Bale is a high-fiber nutritious sun-cured bale that supports the digestive health of growing small animals like rabbits and guinea pigs. Made from all-natural ingredients, it contains no artificial color or preservatives. Provide this Kaytee alfalfa in a bin, feed hopper or just loose for small animals to consume every day. The amount to offer depends on the size of the animal. This product contains a minimum of 17 percent crude protein, 1.5 percent crude fat, 30.0 percent crude fiber and 12 percent moisture. Give your pet a high-roughage diet and keep them healthy with this bale.

Kaytee Natural Alfalfa Mini-Bale: High protein Natural high-fiber hay NET WT 24 OZ (680 g) Premium Kaytee alfalfa mini bales help support a healthy diet and complement any Kaytee fortified food Supports digestive health Contains no artificial colors or preservatives For growing animals

5. Extreme Timothy Hay 96oz

Extreme Timothy Hay 96oz
84%

Our Score

Extreme Timothy Hay 96oz

F M Brown Merchandise Timothy Hay 96oz Small Animal Food

6. CareFresh Timothy Hay Small Animal Food, 32 Oz

CareFresh Timothy Hay Small Animal Food, 32 Oz
74%

Our Score

CareFresh Timothy Hay Small Animal Food A division of Healthy Pet, CareFresh offers natural bedding for small mammal pets with excellent odor control and absorbency. Grown in the nutrient-rich soil in Eastern Washington State, Carefresh 100% Timothy Hay provides ideal daily nutrition. 30% fiber for proper digestion, this hay helps small animals digest food efficiently. This product uses only the first cut of hay for ideal protein, fiber and fat ratios; the first cut is slightly harder than other cuts to wear down and clean small animals' ever-growing teeth. Carefresh 100% Timothy Hay is great for rabbits, guinea pigs, chinchillas and other small animals. Ingredients: 100% Timothy Hay. Guaranteed Analysis: CRUDE PROTEIN 8.1% min. CRUDE FAT 1.9% min. CRUDE FAT 3.5% max. CRUDE FIBER 30.1% max. MOISTURE 7.3% max

CareFresh Timothy Hay Small Animal Food, 32 Oz

7. Extreme Timothy Hay 48oz

Extreme Timothy Hay 48oz
68%

Our Score

Extreme Timothy Hay 48oz

F M Brown Merchandise Timothy Hay 48oz Small Animal Food

8. Small Pet Select Hand Made Hay Manger, Large

Small Pet Select Hand Made Hay Manger, Large
0%

Our Score

Size: Large | Product details Our Head Toy Elf, Duncan, has created hay mangers with NO glues, No screws, NO nails. Just safe wood, and safe rope. These are just the most small-animal friendly mangers in existence! 2 sizes: Small: works for mini-lops, mini-Rexes, and other rabbits under about 6 pounds. Guinea pigs are hay monsters so really should go with larger size. Large: works great for guinea pigs and buns over 6 lbs. Remember: you want your animal to EAT a nice compact pile of hay about the same size as their body EVERY DAY. PS: these mangers work very well over a litter box.

Small Pet Select Hand Made Hay Manger, Large

9. Extreme! Botanical Hay 24oz

Extreme! Botanical Hay 24oz
0%

Our Score

Extreme! Botanical Hay 24oz

F M Brown Merchandise Timothy Hay 24oz Small Animal Food

10. Small Pet Select - Flower Power Berry Boost Herbal Blend

Small Pet Select - Flower Power Berry Boost Herbal Blend
0%

Our Score

Small Pet Select - Flower Power Berry Boost Herbal Blend

Small Pet Select - Flower Power Berry Boost Herbal Blend


arrow_upward